Crutches vs. Walker: Which Is Better for Non-Weight Bearing Injuries?

*Some links within this post are affiliate links. This means if you purchase something, I may get a small commission at no cost to you. I would not link to something I don't recommend to my clients. Check out our privacy policy for more information.

If you’re non-weight bearing after surgery or injury, you’re probably wondering: should I use crutches or a walker?

I’m Dr. Shawn, Your PT Guy, and I’ve seen this debate play out more times than I can count. Both crutches and walkers have their perks—and their pitfalls. Let’s break it down so you can decide which makes the most sense for your recovery (and your sanity).

And before I forget—want to learn how to prevent falls while you’re navigating this recovery stage? Check out my Fall Proof Webinar for practical training you can use right away.

The Case for Crutches

Crutches are the Usain Bolt of mobility aids: fast, lightweight, and perfect for folks with balance and arm strength.

Pros:

  • Quick to move around
  • Easy to maneuver tight spaces
  • Portable

Cons:

  • Less stable
  • Tiring on your arms and shoulders
  • Awkward when sitting down (where do you put them?)

Crutches are best if you’re younger, stronger, and a little more coordinated—or just determined to zoom around.

The Case for a Walker

Walkers are the tortoise: slower, but way more stable.

Pros:

  • Rock-solid stability
  • Always right there when you sit or stand
  • Easier to use with less balance required

Cons:

  • Slower pace
  • Bulkier to maneuver
  • Not as convenient for stairs or tight corners

If safety is your top concern (and let’s be real, it should be), walkers are the MVP.

Which Should You Choose?

  • If you want speed and have the strength → Crutches.
  • If you want stability and safety → Walker.

Personally, I recommend walkers for most people, especially if fall risk is an issue. And speaking of falls, that’s exactly why I put together my Fall Proof Webinar—to keep you safe while moving through recovery and beyond.

FAQs

Q: Can I switch between crutches and a walker?
A: Yes! Many people use both depending on the situation (walker at home, crutches for quick trips).

Q: Are walkers safe on stairs?
A: No. For stairs, crutches (or better yet, handrails) are the way to go.

Q: How do I know if my crutches are the right height?
A: About two finger widths under your armpit, and elbows slightly bent at the handles.

Q: How else can I reduce fall risk?
A: Excellent question. I already talked about the Fall Proof webinar, but if you're interested in specific ways to reduce fall risk at home, my book, Don't Fall reveals 101 ways to reduce your fall risk at home.

Final Word from Dr. Shawn

Both crutches and walkers have their place, but the key is choosing what keeps you moving safely. My advice? Don’t just focus on speed—focus on fall prevention.

For that and more tips on staying independent (and upright), sign up for my Fall Proof Webinar and let’s keep you moving with confidence.

—Dr. Shawn, Your PT Guy



You may also like

Free 3 Secrets to a Fall Proof Life Webinar Training

In This Free Training with Dr. Shawn 
You'll Learn:

  • The 2 biggest lies you might believe about falls 
  • Why your home isn't as safe as you think it is
  • Quick, simple ways anyone can use to begin reducing fall risk at home immediately
  • The Bar Stool Balance concept and how to actually "improve your balance" by focusing on 4 key areas